A typology of Roma misrepresentation in contemporary Europe: Marginalization, denizenship, suppression and co-option
Abstract
Building on David Theo Goldberg’s account of the racial state and empirical research on Roma people in Europe, this article delineates various ways in which racism can undermine political representation. To that end it deploys Nancy Fraser’s concepts of “ordinary-political misrepresentation” and “misframing”; the all-affected/subjected principle used to identify those entitled to influence political decisions; and Hannah Pitkin’s four-dimensional conception of representation as substantive, formal, descriptive and symbolic. The article distinguishes racialized forms of misrepresentation rooted in everyday discrimination and educational exclusion (marginalization), the denial of citizenship (denizenship), the negation of subjectively held cultural identities (suppression) and the capture of minority leaders (co-option). It suggests that the first constitutes an “ordinary-political” form of inequality among citizens, whereas the latter three violate the all-affected/subjected principle through the misframing of the legitimate policymaking constituency.
Recived: 22 February 2025
Accepted: 09 June 2025
Downloads
References
Akkan, Basak. 2018. Roma and representative justice in Turkey. ETHOS working paper 5.2. Accessed June 16, 2005: https://bpb-eu-w2.wpmucdn.com/blogs.bristol.ac.uk/dist/e/505/files/2025/06/5.2Turkey.pdf.
Anderson, Bridget and Pier-Luc Dupont. 2018. How does it feel to be a problem? What we can learn about justice as political representation from empirical case studies. ETHOS report 5.2. Accessed June 16, 2005: https://bpb-eu-w2.wpmucdn.com/blogs.bristol.ac.uk/dist/e/505/files/2025/06/5.2.-Justice-as-political-representation.pdf.
Anderson, Bridget, Dora-Olivia Vicol, Pier-Luc Dupont and Julia Morris. 2018. Political representation and experienced recognition among Roma in the UK. ETHOS working paper 5.2. Accessed June 16, 2005: https://bpb-eu-w2.wpmucdn.com/blogs.bristol.ac.uk/dist/e/505/files/2025/06/5.2UK.pdf.
Anderson, Bridget. 2013. Us and them? The dangerous politics of immigration controls. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Araújo, Sara and Laura Brito. 2018. Tensions between institutionalized political justice and experienced (mis)recognition: Portuguese case study on the experiences of Roma communities. ETHOS working paper 5.2. Accessed June 16, 2005: https://bpb-eu-w2.wpmucdn.com/blogs.bristol.ac.uk/dist/e/505/files/2025/06/5.2Portugal.pdf.
Arrighi, Jean T., Rainer Bauböck, Derek Hutcheson, Alina Ostling and Lorenzo Piccoli. 2019. Conditions for Electoral Rights 2019. European University Institute. Accessed June 16, 2005: https://globalcit.eu/conditions-for-electoral-rights/.
Baclija, Irena, Marjan Brezovsek and Miro Hacek. 2008. «Positive discrimination of the Roma minority: The case of Roma local councillors in Slovenia.» Ethnicities 8(2): 227-250.
Bauböck, Rainer, Joseph H. Carens, Sean W.D. Gray, Jennifer C. Rubenstein and Melissa Williams. 2019. «Democratic inclusion beyond the state?» Contemporary Political Theory 18: 88–114.
Bosniak, Linda. 2006. The citizen and the alien: Dilemmas of contemporary membership. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Burton, Andrew. 2007. «Minority self-governance: Minority representation in flux for the Hungarian Roma», Ethnopolitics 6(1): 67-88.
Caglar, Ayse. 2016. «Displacement of European citizen Roma in Berlin: Acts of citizenship and sites of contentious politics.» Citizenship Studies 20(5): 647–663.
Clough, Isabella and Ulderico Daniele. 2014. «A failed Roma revolution: Conflict, fragmentation and status quo maintenance in Rome.» Ethnicities 14(6): 775–792.
Clough, Isabella and Ulderico Daniele. 2011. «Roma and humanitarianism in the Eternal City», Journal of Modern Italian Studies 16(5): 621-636.
Csepeli, György and Dávid Simon. 2004. «Construction of Roma identity in Eastern and Central Europe: Perception and self-identification», Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 30(1): 129–150.
De Genova, Nicholas. 2016. «The ‘European’ question: Migration, race, and post-coloniality in ‘Europe’», in An anthology of migration and social transformation: European perspectives, ed. Anna A., Kenneth Horvath and Bruno Meeus, 343–356. Cham: Springer.
Dupont, Pier-Luc. 2025. Anti-racism, multiculturalism and human rights: Reconceiving the politics of diversity in employment and education. Cham: Palgrave.
European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. 2018. A persisting concern: Anti-Gypsyism as a barrier to Roma inclusion. Publications Office of the European Union. Accessed June 16, 2005: https://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra_uploads/fra-2018-anti-gypsyism-barrier-roma-inclusion_en.pdf.
Faure-Atger, Anaïs. 2013. «European citizenship revealed: Sites, actors and Roma access to justice in the EU», in Enacting European citizenship, edited by Engin Isin and Michael Saward, 178-194. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fekete, Liz. 2014. «Europe against the Roma.» Race and Class 55(3): 60-70.
Feldman, David. 2012. «Conservative pluralism and the politics of multiculturalism», in Secularism, Racism and the Politics of Belonging, edited by Nira Yuval-Davis and Philip Marfleet, 10-12. London: Runnymede.
Fox, Jon E., Laura Morosanu and Eszter Szilassy. 2012. «The racialization of the new European migration to the UK.» Sociology 46(4): 680–695.
Fraser, Nancy. 2009. Scales of justice: Reimagining political space in a globalizing world. New York: Columbia University Press.
Fraser, Nancy. 2000. «Rethinking recognition.» New Left Review 3: 107–120.
Fraser, Nancy. 1995. «From redistribution to recognition? Dilemmas of justice in a ‘post-socialist’ age.» New Left Review I/212: 68–93.
Fredman, Sandra. 2016. «Substantive equality revisited.» International Journal of Constitutional Law 14(3): 712-738.
Fredman, Sandra. 2008. Human rights transformed: Positive rights and positive duties. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Garner, Steve. 2016. A moral economy of whiteness: Four frames of racialising discourse. Abingdon: Routledge.
Gay y Blasco, Paloma. 2002. «Gypsy/Roma diasporas. A comparative perspective.» Social Anthropology 10(2): 173–188.
Goldberg, David T. 2006. «Racial Europeanization.» Ethnic and Racial Studies 29(2): 331-364.
Goldberg, David T. 2002. The racial state. Oxford: Blackwell.
Goodin, Robert. 2007. «Enfranchising all affected interests, and its alternatives.» Philosophy and Public Affairs 35(1): 40–68.
Grill, Jan. 2018. «‘In England, they don’t call you black!’ Migrating racialisations and the production of Roma differences across Europe.» Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 44(7): 1136–1155.
Gutmann, Amy. 1999. Democratic Education. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Hammar, Tomas. 1990. Democracy and the nation state: Aliens, denizens and citizens in a world of international migration. Aldershot: Avebury.
Hepworth, Kate. 2014. «Encounters with the clandestine/a and the nomad: The emplaced and embodied constitution of non-citizenship.» Citizenship Studies 18(1): 1–14.
Hepworth, Kate. 2012. «Abject citizens: Italian ‘Nomad Emergencies’ and the deportability of Romanian Roma.» Citizenship Studies 16(3–4): 431-449.
Hiah, Jing and Trudie Knijn. 2018. Country report on the current and historical minoritization of Roma minorities in the Netherlands. ETHOS working paper 5.2. Accessed June 16, 2025: https://bpb-eu-w2.wpmucdn.com/blogs.bristol.ac.uk/dist/e/505/files/2025/06/5.2Netherlands.pdf.
Humphris, Rachel. 2019. «Mutating faces of the state? Austerity, migration and faith-based volunteers in a UK downscaled urban context.» The Sociological Review 67(1): 95-110.
Humphris, Rachel. 2018. «On the threshold: Becoming Romanian Roma, everyday racism and residency rights in transition.» Social Identities 24(4): 505–519.
Ignatoiu-Sora, Emanuela. 2011. «The discrimination discourse in relation to the Roma: Its limits and benefits.» Ethnic and Racial Studies 34(10): 1697– 1714.
Jeffers, Kristen, Iseult Honohan and Rainer Bauböck. 2017. How to measure the purposes of citizenship laws: Explanatory report for the CITLAW indicators. European University Institute. Accessed June 16, 2025: https://globalcit.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/CITLAW_3.0.pdf.
Kaneva, Nadia and Delia Popescu. 2014. «‘We are Romanian, not Roma’: Nation branding and postsocialist discourses of alterity.» Communication, Culture and Critique 7: 511–512.
Khanna, Vandita. 2024. «Roma vulnerability before the European Court of Human Rights: Towards a structural account.» Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights 42(4): 340-362.
Kóczé, Angéla. 2018. «Race, migration and neoliberalism: Distorted notions of Romani migration in European public discourses.» Social Identities 24(4): 459-473.
Kóczé, Angéla and Márton Rövid. 2012. «Pro-Roma global civil society: Acting for, with or instead of Roma?», in Global civil society 2012: Ten years of critical reflection, edited by Mary Kaldor, Henrietta L. Moore and Sabine Selchow, 110–123. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Kostka, Joanna. 2019. «The migrating poor: Romanian Roma under social authoritarianism in Poland», in Constructing Roma migrants: European narratives and local governance, edited by Tina Magazzini and Stefano Piemontese, 155-174. Cham: Springer.
Kovai, Cecília. 2012. «Hidden potentials in ‘naming the Gypsy’: The transformation of the Gypsy-Hungarian distinction», in The Gypsy ‘Menace’: Populism and the new anti-Gypsy politics, edited by Michael Stewart, 281–294. London: Hurst and Company.
Krizsán, Andrea. 2012. «Group self-determination, individual rights, or social inclusion? Competing frames for ethnic counting in Hungary.» Ethnic and Racial Studies 35(8): 1392-1408.
Kymlicka, Will. 2000. «Nation-building and minority rights: Comparing West and East.» Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 26(2): 183-212.
Kymlicka, Will. 1995. Multicultural citizenship: A liberal theory of minority rights. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Laparra, Miguel and Almudena Macías. 2009. «Spanish Gitanos, Romani migrants and European Roma identity: (Re)unification or self-affirmation?» in Romani politics in contemporary Europe: Poverty, ethnic mobilization, and the neoliberal order, edited by Nando Sigona and Nidhi Trehan, 226– 245. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Leahy, Sharon. 2014. «Demonising discourse: The Traveller Community’s struggle against the elite voice of RTE.» Romani Studies 24(2): 165–201.
Leggio, Daniele Viktor. 2019. «‘Modern-day Fagins’, ‘gaudy mansions’ and ‘increasing numbers’: Narratives on Roma migrants in the build-up to the British EU referendum», in Constructing Roma migrants: European narratives and local governance, edited by Tina Magazzini and Stefano Piemontese, 69-90. City: Springer.
Magazzini, Tina. 2016. «Cultural institutions as a combat sport. Reflections on the European Roma Institute.» The Age of Human Rights Journal 7: 50-76.
Margalit, Gilad and Yaron Matras. 2007. «Gypsies in Germany – German Gypsies? Identity and politics of Sinti and Roma in Germany” in The Roma: A minority in Europe. Historical, political and social perspectives, edited by Roni Stauber and Raphael Vago, 103-116. Budapest: Central European University Press.
Marusák, Martin and Leo Singer. 2009. «Social unrest in Slovakia 2004: Romani reaction to neoliberal ‘reforms’” in Romani politics in contemporary Europe: Poverty, ethnic mobilization, and the neoliberal order, edited by Nando Sigona and Nidhi Trehan, 186-208. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Marushiakova, Elena and Vesselin Popov. 2013. «‘Gypsy’ groups in Eastern Europe: Ethnonyms vs. professionyms.” Romani Studies 23(1): 61–81.
McGarry, Aidan. 2014. «Roma as a political identity: Exploring representations of Roma in Europe.» Ethnicities 14(6): 756–774.
McGarry, Aidan. 2010. Who speaks for Roma? Political representation of a transnational minority community. New York: Continuum.
McGarry, Aidan. 2009. «Ambiguous nationalism? Explaining the parliamentary under-representation of Roma in Hungary and Romania”, Romani Studies 19(2): 103–124.
Meier, Isabella and Maddalena Vivona. 2018. The tension between institutionalised political justice in Austria and Roma’s experienced (mis) recognition. ETHOS working paper 5.2. Accessed June 16, 2005: https://bpb-eu-w2.wpmucdn.com/blogs.bristol.ac.uk/dist/e/505/files/2025/06/5.2Austria.pdf.
Modood, Tariq. 2007. Multiculturalism: A civic idea. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Modood, Tariq and Simon Thompson. 2018. «Revisiting contextualism in political theory: Putting principles into context.» Res Publica 24: 339-357.
Morosanu, Laura and Jon Fox. 2013. «‘No smoke without fire’: Strategies of coping with stigmatised migrant identities.» Ethnicities 13(4): 438–456.
Möschel, Mathias. 2011. «Race in mainland European legal analysis: Towards a European critical race theory.» Ethnic and Racial Studies 34(10): 1648- 1664.
Nacu, Alexandra. 2012. «From silent marginality to spotlight scapegoating? A brief case study of France’s policy towards the Roma.» Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 38(8): 1323–1328.
Näsström, Sofia. 2011. «The challenge of the all-affected principle.» Political Studies 59: 116–134.
Nordberg, Camilla. 2006. «Claiming citizenship: Marginalised voices on identity and belonging.» Citizenship Studies 10(5): 523–539.
O’Nions, Helen. 2015. «Warehouses and window-dressing: A legal perspective on educational segregation in Europe.» ZEP: Zeitschrift fuer Internationale Bildungsforschung und Entwicklungspaedagogik 38(1): 4–10.
Parekh, Bhikhu. 2000. Rethinking multiculturalism: Cultural diversity and political theory. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Patten, Alan. 2014. Equal recognition: The moral foundations of minority rights. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Pitkin, Hannah. 1967. The concept of representation. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Plaut, Shayna. 2017. «Follow the money: International donors, external homelands and their effect on Romani media and advocacy.» Ethnic and Racial Studies 40(7): 1058-1076.
Prieto-Flores, Òscar and Teresa Sordé-Martí. 2011. «The institutionalization of panethnicity from the grassroots standpoint in a European context: The case of Gitanos and Roma immigrants in Barcelona.» Ethnicities 11(2): 202-217.
Roma Support Group. 2017. Written evidence submitted by Roma Support Group (RSG) (GRT0044). Accessed June 16, 2005: http://data.parliament.uk/WrittenEvidence/CommitteeEvidence.svc/EvidenceDocument/Women%20and%20Equalities/Tackling%20inequalities%20faced%20by%20the%20Gypsy,%20Roma%20and%20Traveller%20communities/Written/46222.html.
Roman, Raluca B. 2014. «Trans-national migration and the issue of ‘ethnic’ solidarity: Finnish Roma elite and Eastern European Roma migrants in Finland.» Ethnicities 14(6): 793-810.
Rostas, Iulius. 2009. «The Romani movement in Romania: Institutionalization and (de)mobilization», in Romani politics in contemporary Europe: Poverty, ethnic mobilization, and the neoliberal order, edited by Nando Sigona and Nidhi Trehan, 159–185. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Rovid, Márton. 2011. «One-size-fits-all Roma? On the normative dilemmas of the emerging European Roma policy.» Romani Studies 21(1): 1–22.
Schafft, Kai A. and Roland Ferkovics. 2018. «Roma political agency and spaces of social inclusion and exclusion: The contradictions of Roma self-governance amidst the rise of Hungary’s radical right.» Ethnic and Racial Studies 41(11): 2009–2027.
Sharma, Nandita. 2020. Home rule: National sovereignty and the separation of natives and migrants. Durham: Duke University Press.
Sigona, Nando. 2015. «Campzenship: Reimagining the camp as a social and political space.» Citizenship Studies 19(1): 1–15.
Sigona, Nando. 2011. «The governance of Romani people in Italy: Discourse, policy and practice.» Journal of Modern Italian Studies 16(5): 590–606.
Stewart, Michael. 2012. «Populism, Roma and the European politics of cultural difference», in The Gypsy ‘Menace’: Populism and the new anti-Gypsy politics, edited by Michael Stewart, 3–23. London: Hurst and Company.
United Kingdom Conservative and Unionist Party. 2019. Get Brexit done: Unleash Britain’s potential. Accessed June 16, 2005: https://assets-global.website-files.com/5da42e2cae7ebd3f8bde353c/5dda924905da587992a064ba_Conservative%202019%20Manifesto.pdf.
Valadez, Jorge. 2001. Deliberative democracy, political legitimacy, and self-determination in multicultural societies. Boulder: Westview Press.
Vermeersch, Peter. 2003. «Ethnic minority identity and movement politics: The case of the Roma in the Czech Republic and Slovakia.» Ethnic and Racial Studies 26(5): 879-901.
Voiculescu, Cerasela. 2017. European social integration and the Roma: Questioning neoliberal governmentality. London: Routledge.
Vrabiescu, Ioana. 2017. «Roma migrant children in Catalonia: Between the politics of benevolence and the normalization of violence.» Ethnic and Racial Studies 40(10): 1663–1680.
Vrabiescu, Ioana and Barak Kalir. 2018. «Care-full failure: How auxiliary assistance to poor Roma migrant women in Spain compounds marginalization.» Social Identities 24(4): 520–532.
Walzer, Michael. 1983. Spheres of justice: A defense of pluralism and equality. New York: Basic Books.
Wemyss, Georgie and Kathryn Cassidy. 2017. «‘People think that Romanians and Roma are the same’: Everyday bordering and the lifting of transitional controls.» Ethnic and Racial Studies 40(7): 1132–1150.
Yildiz, Can and Nicholas De Genova. 2018. «Un/Free mobility: Roma migrants in the European Union.» Social Identities 24(4): 425–441.
Young, Iris Marion. 2000. Inclusion and democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Yuval-Davis, Nira, Georgie Wemyss and Kathryn Cassidy. 2018. «Everyday bordering, belonging and the reorientation of British immigration legislation.» Sociology 52(2): 228–244.
Zala, Miklós, Simon Rippon, Tom Theuns, Sem de Maagt and Bert van den Brink. 2020. «From political philosophy to messy empirical reality», in Justice and vulnerability in Europe: An interdisciplinary approach, edited by Trudie Knijn and Dorota Lepianka, 37-53. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Zemandl, Eva. 2018. The Roma experience of political (in)justice: The case of school (de)segregation in Hungary. ETHOS working paper 5.2. Accessed June 16, 2005: https://bpb-eu-w2.wpmucdn.com/blogs.bristol.ac.uk/dist/e/505/files/2025/06/5.2Hungary.pdf.
Zolnay, János. 2012. «Abusive language and discriminatory measures in Hungarian local policy», in The Gypsy ‘Menace’: Populism and the new anti-Gypsy politics, edited by Michael Stewart 25–42. London: Hurst and Company.
Copyright (c) 2025 University of Deusto
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Deusto Journal of Human Rights / Revista Deusto de Derechos Humanos is an Open Access journal; which means that it is free for full and immediate access, reading, search, download, distribution, and reuse in any medium only for non-commercial purposes and in accordance with any applicable copyright legislation, without prior permission from the copyright holder (University of Deusto) or the author; provided the original work and publication source are properly cited (Issue number, year, pages and DOI if applicable) and any changes to the original are clearly indicated. Any other use of its content in any medium or format, now known or developed in the future, requires prior written permission of the copyright holder.
3.jpg)
3.jpg)
3.jpg)
.jpg)
